The mini-mixer break was broadcast live at 4 PM CST on 9/28/2018. The break was recorded and a full table of results is available below.
| 1960 | Topps | Carl Yastzemski | PSA 7 | 1. Jeffrey Gaughan |
| 1962 | Post | Mickey Mantle | PSA 5 | 2. Jon Morrissey |
| 1969 | Topps | Nolan Ryan | G/VG (light creasing) | 3. Justin Atwood |
| 1960 | Topps | Ernie Banks | PSA 6 | 4. Taylor Napier |
| 1964 | Topps | Lou Brock | EX-MT | 5. ANGELO TORELLO |
| 1960 | Topps | Warren Spahn | PSA 6 | 6. Bill Floyd |
| 1952 | Topps | Phil Rizzuto | G/VG (MK – light mk on back, light crease) | 7. Alex Niedzielski |
| 1952 | Topps | Duke Snider | G (MK – light mk on back, crease) | 8. Bobby hilo |
| 1963 | Topps | Willie Mays | G/VG (very light creasing) | 9. Arron Duff |
| 1969 | Topps | Johnny Bench | VG+ | 10. GEORGE DYSINGER |
| 1954 | Topps | Warren Spahn | G/VG | 11. jeffrey sly |
| 1969 | Topps | Roberto Clemente | VG | 12. Nathan Shelton |
| 1959 | Topps | Robin Roberts | EX | 13. Duke Puckett |
| 1960 | Topps | Al Kaline | VG-EX | 14. John Laven |
| 1960 | Topps | Whitey Ford | VG-EX | 15. Matthew Pottle |
| 1960 | Topps | Ed Mathews | VG-EX | 16. Nick Diehl |
| 1963 | Topps | Al Kaline | GD | 17. Robert Morris |
| 1969 | Topps | Ernie Banks | VG-EX | 18. James Ferguson |