| 1 | 1960 | Topps | 148 | Carl Yastrzemski | SGC 5 EX | 1. Jeffrey Gaughan |
| 2 | 1960 | Topps | 563 | Mickey Mantle AS | PSA 5 EX | 2. Randy Jones |
| 3 | 1960 | Topps | 343 | Sandy Koufax | PSA 4 VG-EX | 3. David Clubb |
| 4 | 1971 | Topps | 20 | Reggie Jackson | EX | 4. Joseph Cerullo |
| 5 | 1965 | Topps | 485 | Nellie Fox | EX | 5. jeffrey sly |
| 6 | 1964 | Topps | 41 | McCovey/Wagner | VG-EX | 6. Nathan Shelton |
| 7 | 1970 | Topps | 290 | Rod Carew | EX-MT | 7. Daniel Rauer |
| 8 | 1972 | Topps | 50 | Willie Mays IA | EX | 8. Patrick Kennedy |
| 9 | 1972 | Topps | 441 | Thurman Munson | VG-EX | 9. Bobby hilo |
| 10 | 1964 | Topps | 182 | Yastrzemski/Schilling | VG-EX | 10. Mark Wectawski |